The Myth of the Hungry Heart

Austin Gardner • December 23, 2022

The Hindu, the Buddhist, the Muslim, and the Confucianist all consider their religion superior to ours

Missionaries do not find hundreds ready to accept Christ. It is real work to go out and share the gospel and slowly one by one see God do a work. Read this article and pray for your missionary.


Few Christians have an adequate understanding of the enormous difficulties inherent in the conversion of the non-Christian peoples of the world. It is assumed that the “heathen” in their moral and spiritual degradation are expectantly awaiting the coming of the missionary; his arrival will be the signal for them to abandon their evil ways and embrace the gospel.

Missionary speakers, literature, and hymns have all contributed to this view. The “heathen” have been depicted as sitting in darkness, living in fear, and dying without hope. They have been variously described as forsaken, benighted, depraved, debauched, and deluded. Much has been made of the phenomenon of fear—fear of sickness, ancestors, evil spirits, angry gods, natural disasters, and finally, death.

Surely these people in their more sober moments must be aware of their plight. Given an opportunity they will readily accept the Christian message with its offer of life, health, joy, peace, and power.

What are the facts? That the non-Christian peoples of the world are lost in the darkness of sin, living in fear, and dying without hope is true. That they are ready and eager to accept Christ is not true. From time to time missionaries have come across certain individuals who believed the gospel the first time they heard it. They are the exception, not the rule. The overwhelming majority of non-Christian peoples must be included in Paul’s statement: “None is righteous, no, not one; no one understands, no one seeks for God. All have turned aside, together they have gone wrong; no one does good, not even one” (Ro3:10-12).

There is no evidence to support the view expressed in a well- known missionary hymn to the effect that “the heathen in his blindness” is calling on us to “deliver him from errors chain.” He is not aware of his blindness, nor does he feel the weight of any chain. The Hindu, the Buddhist, the Muslim, and the Confucianist all consider their religion superior to ours; hence they are in no hurry to give it up. As for the peasant in his paddy field, he is so engrossed in the problem of feeding his large family that he has neither time nor thought for the needs of his soul. His chief concern is not where he will spend eternity, but how he and his children will survive until harvest. The same goes for the shopkeeper in the bazaar, the worker in the factory, and the housewife in the home. And if the time comes

It would be foolish, of course, to deny that some doors have already closed or that others will close in the future. What we do deny is that sooner or later all doors will close and the missionaries will find themselves without employment. Neither the lessons of history nor the statements of Scripture oblige us to accept that melancholy conclusion.


 J. Herbert Kane, Understanding Christian Missions


By Austin Gardner • October 7, 2026
How to Build a School That Fits the People God Gave You
By Austin Gardner • October 6, 2026
It Grows Out of a Church That Is Already Making Disciples
By Austin Gardner • October 5, 2026
What a shoemaker taught the church about reaching the world
By Austin Gardner • October 4, 2026
What five loaves teach us about reaching the world
By Austin Gardner • October 3, 2026
Setting mission priorities that match the Father’s heart
By Austin Gardner • October 2, 2026
What is a sender?
By Austin Gardner • October 1, 2026
Practical Ways to Care for Your Missionary in the Final Weeks
By Austin Gardner • September 30, 2026
How Yokefellow Teams Are Formed
By Austin Gardner • September 29, 2026
Why Every Missionary Needs a Team Back Home
By Austin Gardner • September 28, 2026
Priorities for Reaching the Nations